Understanding

entendement

Worked through in 14 videos · 23 passages.

What Dominique Pagani says

Dominique Pagani takes from Kant the distinction between understanding (Verstand) and reason (Vernunft): understanding is the intellect at work in the natural sciences and in common sense1. Of the three faculties, it is the middle one, between sensibility, which we share with animals, and reason, the faculty of ends. He links it to Plato's dianoia, the hypothetico-deductive knowledge of "if… then", of which mathematics is the perfect form2. With Hegel, who criticises it in Kant but rehabilitates it against the Romantics, he sees in it the absolute power of dividing, that is, of analysing, of isolating in thought what is not isolated in reality3 4. This power is necessary but not sufficient: it suits the laws of objects, not those of subjects5. He calls it ambivalent, like money. An intelligence of the understanding can go together with blindness, and it becomes terrifying when it is neither engaged with the reality of sensibility nor enlightened by reason6. It is also the "mechanical reason" that machines can access.

Summary produced automatically from 23 of the passages below, to be reviewed; the numbers link to the moment in the session.

Season 13 · 25 Jul 2025Naturalist ideology / Answers to questions - Dominique Pagani

50:11German distinguishes Verstand and Vernunft; understanding suits the laws of objects, not those of subjects.

Talks · 2 Dec 2024"Napoleon, or the reasons of cunning", with Dominique Pagani

10:59The reason at work in machines and the sciences is the understanding, a distinction owed to Kant.
32:51Science has as its criterion true and false, not good and evil.

Season 11 · 22 Jul 2023Worldliness in Clouscard - The world as "cunning of reason"

13:57Understanding (Verstand, intellectus) is at work in the natural sciences, with the logic of "if, then"; it works with experience, from a being-there.

Series · 20 May 2021Cynicism of the extreme centre or epistemic heroism? The dialectic of the middle • Dominique Pagani

19:28Of the three Kantian faculties, understanding is the one of the milieu, pure intelligence without affectivity.
1:01:37It is the faculty of the milieu, between sensibility, which we share with animals, and reason, the faculty of ends.

Season 9.2 · 12 May 20219 #21 Science and/or philosophy of "Artificial Intelligence"

1:49:24Understanding is the "if, then," a mechanical reason to which the machine can have access; Hegel criticizes it and rehabilitates it against the romantics.

Season 9.2 · 14 Jan 20219 #12 How can sciences of history be real?

16:16The median faculty between sensibility and reason, Plato's dianoia: hypothetico-deductive knowledge of the "if… then," the ruling faculty of the hard sciences.
27:28The extreme right is all the more dangerous for being intelligent in the sense of understanding.
1:57:10It becomes terrifying when it is neither grappling with the reality of sensibility nor illuminated by reason, the faculty of ends.

Season 9.1 · 8 Oct 2020#1 Benefits and harms of amnesia...

14:15The intelligence of the understanding, that of if-then, can be great without sparing one from blindness.
1:10:42Distinct from dialectical reason, which in the historical sciences reconstructs sequences.

Season 8 · 21 Jun 2020#11 • Return to the logics of the subject

46:23Inherited from Kant, it is the intellect that holds to non-contradiction. It divides and analyzes, that is, decomposes: it is an absolute power, necessary but not sufficient.

Season 7 · 17 May 2020#8 • Harnessed to confinitude

1:24:32The understanding detects error and contradiction, but refuses to penetrate contradiction internal to the subject.
1:31:23Scorned by the Romantics as mediate knowledge, the understanding's function is analysis: to isolate through thought what in reality is not isolated.

Season 5.1 · 6 Dec 2018#5.2 ter FaceBookLive / Questions (2) following Workshop #5.2

44:22A median faculty between sensibility and reason, despised by the romantics; Hegel makes it the absolute power of the negative, the activity of dividing.

Season 3 · 1 Aug 2017#3.5 From Ulysses to Daedalus

1:08:49The activity of dividing, analysis, is the strength and the work of the understanding, absolute power according to Hegel.

Season 3 · 1 Aug 2017#3.6 From Ulysses to Daedalus

10:01Dividing is the force and the work of understanding, the absolute power. Between sensibility and reason, it is intelligence in the abstract sense, which need not be reductive.

Series · 2 Feb 2016Hegel on the Beach 3/5

1:04:39A faculty of which mathematics is the perfection: linking statements under the principle of non-contradiction, without deciding anything about existence.
1:08:43It separates; Hegel criticizes it in Kant but rehabilitates it against the Romantics as the absolute power of dividing.

Series · 1 Feb 2016Hegel on the Beach 1/5

20:04Distinguished from reason since Kant, the understanding (Verstand) is the intellect at work in science and in common sense.
1:17:37The activity of dividing is the power of the understanding, an absolute power that Hegel rehabilitates against the Romantics.
1:25:37A moment of ambivalence: like money, it can serve the worst as much as the best; it is a necessary moment.