Summary
Dominique Pagani consistently distinguishes landscape from nature: the countryside, the bocage, hedges and fields are the product of millennia of human labour, both muscular and intellectual1. He defines landscape as a compromise between what nature provides and human arrangement, and points out that "paese" first means the village, which is the opposite of nature2. He describes it as a surface, an appearance, a screen onto which we project what comes from ourselves, whereas nature lies in depth3. In his view, the enjoyment of landscape becomes possible when the industrial revolution pushes back natural necessity: nature then becomes a spectacle, and its poetry, which appears only at the end of the eighteenth century, comes from the ruling classes4. Finally, he describes an inner landscape, evoked rather than described, from Baudelaire onwards, and suggests that the most beautiful landscapes may be those one hears, in Schubert's music or in Rilke.
- 1#2 Lenin, or the wings of dreams18 Apr 2021 · 30:07
- 2#5.4 Introduction: nature or landscape?25 Jan 2019 · 32:40
- 3#12 Return to the logics of the subject2 Jul 2020 · 1:16:39
- 4Worldliness in Clouscard, or privileges for all18 May 2023 · 2:18:36
Summary produced automatically from 30 of the passages below, to be reviewed; the numbers link to the moment in the session.
Cycle 13 · 27 May 2025Flagrante Delights- 42:22The inner landscape, since Baudelaire: a universe arises with eyes closed, through evocation rather than description.
Cycle 12 · 24 Jun 2024For a “fresh and joyful” apocalypse?- 1:50:53The environment matters more than nature: hedges and fields are a landscape, the product of millennia of human labor.
Cycle 11 · 18 May 2023Worldliness in Clouscard, or privileges for all- 2:18:36When the industrial revolution pushes back natural necessity, man can see nature as a spectacle: it is no longer nature, it is landscape.
Series · 20 May 2022Who is hiding beneath the surfaces? Aesthetics and politics- 1:14:22Landscape is the surface of nature, produced by labor; to defend a Romanesque chapel in a field is to protect the landscape, not nature.
Series · 18 Apr 2021#2 Lenin, or the wings of dreams- 30:07Landscape is not nature but ten thousand years of effort to transform nature, like the Normandy hedgerow country.
Cycle 8 · 2 Jul 2020#12 Return to the logics of the subject- 1:16:39The landscape is the surface of nature that appears for us, a screen onto which we project what comes from within us.
Talks · 29 Sept 2019The religion of money- 33:11The landscape is not nature: it is a compromise between nature and millennia of human labor, both muscular and intellectual.
Talks · 3 Aug 2019Money, work, freedom- 51:05Nature becomes landscape and spectacle when it recedes before industry; the worker does not contemplate it, he has already grasped it.
Cycle 5.2 · 30 Jun 2019#5.8 Nature or landscape?- 11:15Without nature it would not exist, but nature alone is not enough: it presupposes an arrangement by man.
- 1:28:02The ideal landscape is the classless society unconsciously realized, a heavenly Jerusalem.
Cycle 5.2 · 2 May 2019#5.6 Nature or landscape?- 27:01In Rilke, it is not a landscape that offers itself to be seen but a voice that offers itself to be heard.
- 54:05The most beautiful landscapes are perhaps those given to be heard in music.
- 1:12:19In Schubert's andante, the planes are staggered: the strings in the foreground, the flutes in the distance like mountain ridges.
Cycle 5.2 · 26 Mar 2019#5.5 Nature or landscape?- 2:08Nature and landscape are not yet distinguished; they are mistaken for one another in ordinary usage.
- 1:43:13Landscape has never had as much value as when it has vanished into interiority and then re-emerges, transfigured by speech.
Cycle 5.2 · 4 Feb 2019#5.4 Nature or landscape?- 22:02There is decor only for someone: for there to be decor, there must be a spectacle.
- 27:13Paese means village; the peasant was the first to make nature disappear.
- 58:21Landscape in the modern sense, wild and empty of people, expresses a recent culture, ours.
Cycle 5.2 · 25 Jan 2019#5.4 Introduction: nature or landscape?- 32:40Paese, from which "paysage" derives, first designates the village, that is, the opposite of nature.
- 35:23Landscape is a compromise between the natural given and human development. The ideal landscape is Hölderlin's "good town."
- 41:03A landscape can be seen, described, or heard: perhaps the most beautiful are those one hears.
Talks · 20 May 2018Work and the right to work- 40:08The countryside is not nature but a landscape produced by millennia of work.
Cycle 4 · 15 Mar 2018#4.6 Angélique (by Nerval)- 28:26Nature and landscape must not be confused: it takes millennia of effort to make nature into a habitable landscape.
- 47:26The landscape garden: an entirely artificial setting where one believes oneself to be in nature.
- 56:17From Baudelaire onward the landscape is interior: evocation, not description.
Series · 29 Jan 2016What is to be done? 3/3- 27:39Enjoying a landscape is possible only once the industrial revolution makes nature recede.
- 31:48Landscape is a surface, an appearance, not nature, which lies in depth.
Cycle 1 · 14 Sept 2015#1.3 Between crisis and war: philosophising?- 1:04:13Landscape is the product of a millennia-long labor; its poetry appears only at the end of the eighteenth century.
- 1:21:22The poetry of landscape comes from the ruling classes, separated from natural constraint by mediations.
Series · 29 Dec 2014O for Opposition- 19:00The park is not raw nature but landscape; it took millennia to pass from nature to landscape, which has become heritage.